Truly great emailers often fall into 1 of 2 “camps”:
1. A great email copywriter
2. A great email marketer
Rarely is someone equally found in both.
A few fall into extremes.
But, most are slightly tilted one way or the other.
Anyway, here are some “tells” about each:
A great email copywriter will spend hours crafting the perfect subject line — each word carefully chosen using a thesaurus, a swipe file and a pile of magazines, printed out emails and sales letter headlines. He does this because in his heart (often the result of being a trained copywriter) he thinks the headline (subject line) is the most important piece of “real estate” of the entire email.
And, thus the most important part of making the sale.
On the other hand…
A great email marketer knows money is attracted to speed.
He bats his subject lines out FAST.
(Sometimes it’s little more than a brain fart.)
And, he doesn’t worry about it either way — counting on the bond he has with his audience to get a reading more than a subject line will.
A great email copywriter obsesses over metrics.
Like open rates or clickthru rates.
And also which link in the email was clicked most or if the image made any difference in clicks, and so on.
He will be very conversant about email metrics, too.
To him, it’s like a video game:
He just wants to increase his “score” (i.e. his opens and clicks) each time, and that’s how he mainly keeps score.
Not so the great email marketer.
The only “metric” he cares about is did the cash register ring?
If not, the email was a dud.
If it did, it was successful.
He would rather have a 1% open rate and get 10 sales than have 100% opens and zero sales. And if he hits on an especially powerful “nerve” he will write several more emails right after — maybe even for an entire week, milking as much money out of that theme/idea/problem/hot button as possible — judging it’s time to talk about something else not by clicks or opens, but by when sales dwindle down.
A great copywriter mails less frequently.
Maybe, at most, a few times per week.
Reason why is, he opts for quality over quantity, takes great pride in his email writing, and refuses to send anything but the best crafted story or pitch he possibly can.
He also hates opt outs, too.
And, will sometimes even take them personally.
Especially if it’s accompanied by a complaint.
Conversely, a great email marketer mails DAILY.
Sometimes even 2-3 TIMES per day, 7 days per week (especially if he sells in a rabid market of people who are anxious to solve whatever problem his product solves.) In his way of thinking, he’d rather play to win (i.e. make more sales) than play not to lose (not anger his list and get the least amount of opt outs).
Frankly, he celebrates opt outs.
Thinks it’s funny when people complain.
And, in some ways, measures his email’s success (besides the sales) based on the emotional reaction he gets from people who hate him.
A great email copywriter has linking down to a science.
He knows EXACTLY how many links to put in an email.
EXACTLY where to put them.
And EXACTLY how many clicks he can expect.
Since he obsesses over clickthrus, he knows where all the best places to put links are for maximum clicks (i.e. above the fold, in the PS, etc) and spends a lot of time crafting his emails around this “intel” he’s gained from studying all his metrics.
A great email marketer often uses just one link.
Usually, at the end.
And, above his signature.
(He puts as little thought as possible into it.)
He is more concerned with having his email seem natural — like a conversation — than he is on inserting links into an email based on where the most clicks occur. Again, he is all about speed… and knows the less time he puts into one email, the more he has to put into others — so he can have multiple different emails/projects working hard for him instead of just one or two.
Anyway, so there you have it.
Differences between great email copywriters & great email marketers.
Both have their strengths and weaknesses.
And, certain personalities naturally gravitate towards one or the other.
For example, I definitely fall on the side of the marketer vs the copywriter side (and have purposely unlearned many habits I learned over the years of writing copy to make more sales with email). I am all about speed, and getting it done in 15 minutes or so, then moving on to other things.
Life is too short to be chained to a desk all day.
But, I could use a bit more of the email copywriter side.
And vice versa with great email copywriters I know.
The goal is to ultimately embody the best of both worlds.
To be a sort of “bipolar” email badass.
It’s something I work towards each day.
And, you should, too.
Moving on:
The next “Email Players” issue is a doozy:
It shows you 43 different “types” of emails.
Great for email marketers who want to not have to sit there each day wondering what kind of email to write. Simply look at the long list I hand you, pick one, and run with it.
It’s the next best thing to me doing it for you.
What else can you ask for?
(My blood?)
But time grows short.
Subscribe here in time:
www.EmailPlayers.com
Ben Settle